South Africa showing good discipline on defense

Yes a card. Rules state once played is above 90deg up to tackler to bring safely to ground. Word malicious is not stated in rule. Intent doesn't matter.

Scotland on the attack now and testing the South African defense

Ref to the rules

no he turned in JP's arms not a card

Soon Darren

What's malicious about it he was turned beyond the horizontal!!

Scotsman twists is the air which didn't help

I thought intent wasn't a mitigating factor?

According to the laws.